The Madison Fire Island Pines Hotel

$$$$||View on mapFire Island Pines, United States of America22 Atlantic Walk, Fire Island Pines, New York, United States of America, NY 11782|
9.6
Perfect
|41 photos
Check rooms and rates
Check-in
Select date
Check-out
Select date
Rooms and Guests2 Guests, 1 room
The Madison Fire Island Pines Hotel
22 Atlantic Walk, Fire Island Pines, New York, United States of America, NY 11782·View on map
$$$$
Overall Score
Perfect
9.6Perfect
Location10.0
Cleanliness9.7
Staff9.7
Facilities9.5
Comfort9.2
Who stays here
Couples50%
Groups25%
Solo25%

Overview

Overall Score
Perfect
9.6Perfect
Location10.0
Cleanliness9.7
Staff9.7
Facilities9.5
Comfort9.2
Who stays here
Couples50%
Groups25%
Solo25%

Adults-only Fire Island Pines guesthouse with heated year-round pool and complimentary breakfast

Heated Pool & Sun Terrace

The Madison Fire Island Pines offers an outdoor heated swimming pool open all year round. Sun loungers and beach chairs are provided on the sun terrace alongside umbrellas for shade. A complimentary continental breakfast is served daily to all guests.

Accommodations with Garden Views

Each room at Madison Fire Island features a private bathroom with garden or pool views. Rooms include a work desk, hairdryer, and air conditioning for comfort. Interconnected rooms are available, and the property is entirely non-smoking.

Proximity to Beach, Ferry & Nightlife

The Madison guest house is a short 5-minute walk from the beach and less than 1 minute from the Fire Island Pines ferry. Local dining options include Blue Whale and other harbor restaurants, bars, and nightlife venues. Nearby attractions include Ocean Beach and Heckscher State Park.

Pet-Friendly Adults-Only Environment

The Madison Hotel Fire Island is a pet-friendly property that welcomes guests with their pets. The adults-only environment encourages guest interactions and a close-knit community feel. Engaged management provides attentive service and efficient check-in for a smooth arrival.

Spa Services and Social Amenities

The hotel offers spa services and massage treatments for on-site relaxation. Guests can use outdoor swimming pool with sun loungers throughout their stay. Free WiFi is available throughout the property for connectivity.

  • Pool: Heated outdoor pool open year-round
  • Location: 1 min from ferry, 5 min from beach
  • Atmosphere: Adults-only social environment
  • Pet Policy: Pets welcome at the Madison
  • Breakfast: Complimentary continental breakfast daily
  • Rooms: Garden/pool views in every room
Good to know
Check-in/Check-out
from 15:30-21:00
until 12:00
Amenities
Wireless internet is available in the hotel rooms for free.
Other information
Children & extra beds
There are no extra beds provided in a room. 
Pets
Pets are allowed on request.
Building
Number of rooms:8
Price calendar
Check availability and prices for your dates now!

Rooms and availability

Deluxe Queen Room
  • Bed options:
    2 Single beds / 1 King Size Bed
Private Bathroom Double Room
  • Bed options:
    1 King Size Bed / 2 Single beds
Deluxe King Room
  • Bed options:
    2 Single beds / 1 King Size Bed
Show 6 more room typesLess

Facilities

Main facilities

Free Wi-Fi

Free Wi-Fi in rooms

Parking

Parking lot

Baggage storage
24-hour services
Swimming pool

Outdoor swimming pool

Heated swimming pool

Adults only
Private beach

Sun loungers

Beach umbrellas

Pets allowed

Spa & Leisure

  • Heated swimming pool
  • Outdoor swimming pool
  • Beach umbrellas
  • Sun loungers
  • Sun terrace
  • Garden area

Room features

  • Free Wi-Fi in rooms
  • Air conditioning
  • Terrace
Show all facilitiesHide facilities

Essential information about The Madison Fire Island Pines Hotel

💵 Lowest room price 341 US$
📏 Distance to center 100 yd
✈️ Distance to airport 5.7 mi
🧳 Nearest airport Long Island MacArthur, ISP

Location

22 Atlantic Walk, Fire Island Pines, New York, United States of America, NY 11782
Address
The address has been copied.
22 Atlantic Walk, Fire Island Pines, New York, United States of America, NY 11782
Map view
22 Atlantic Walk, Fire Island Pines, New York, United States of America, NY 11782
  • City landmarks
  • Nearby
  • Restaurants
Pavilion
100 yd
Restaurant
Pines Bistro and Martini Bar
100 yd
Restaurant
Canteen
100 yd

Reviews of The Madison Fire Island Pines Hotel

The essence·from guest reviews·past 2 years

We read 17 guest reviews so you don’t have to

One honest summary, pulled from every verified stay—no scrolling through hundreds of reviews.

Guests say: exceptional stay
rated 9+
4.0/ 5
2 reviews
9.6/ 10
15 reviews
4.0/ 5
4 reviews
Check rooms and rates
Check-in
Select date
-
Check-out
Select date
Rooms and Guests2 Guests, 1 room